Blogenspiel

Blogenspiel

     

Monday, April 10, 2006

Er ... Not Really



From the Daily Telegraph (Australia -- not the Torygraph):


British historian Tom Asbridge yesterday hailed the find as the first provable example of actual Knights Templar.

The remains were found beneath the ruined walls of Jacob's Ford, an overthrown

castle dating back to the Crusades, which had been lost for centuries.

They can be dated to the exact day -- August 29, 1179 -- that they were killed by Saladin, the feared Muslim leader who captured the fortress.

"Never before has it been possible to trace their remains to such an exact time in history,' Mr Asbridge said. "This discovery is the equivalent of the Holy Grail to archaeologists and historians. It is unparalleled."


Ok ... first, I thought we already knew that the Templars really existed. And second, No, it's not really like finding the Holy Grail at all. Because the only thing like finding the Holy Grail would be actually finding the Holy Grail. Which may or may not be the cup most appropriate for a simple carpenter and may or may not have been found in the 1940s in Petra by a sexy archaeologist and his father after many encounters with the Nazis. Because in this medievalist's world, Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade is every bit as plausible as the nonsense that Dan Brown writes, and far better because no one ever claimed it might be true. Sheesh.

Update: I've seen comments at other places from several colleagues that this is probably a case of an historian being horrendously misquoted. In terms of the coolness of the discovery, one of my Senior Colleagues points out that knowing an almost exact date for something might be a really good gauge for calibrating other, more traditional dating methods, and thus lead to more accurate dating for other sites -- and that is very cool. Just not pop-culture, Dan Brown, Michael Baigent conspiracy-theory cool.

 

6 Comments:

WHAT???

Yes, the Templars existed! Maybe it's the first confirmable instance of actual Templar bones, but I have a hard time thinking those would have been particularly rare.

Come on, people, they're not that mysterious. The only possible mystery could be what happened to them post-Crusades, post-Philip, because that's when you can start making up all the crap about going underground and being occult and mysterious and whatnot. But DURING the Crusades? Um, no.

Sheesh.

By Anonymous New Kid on the Hallway, at 5:55 PM  

I second the rumble of skepticism! How the heck are they dating the bones to the *exact* day the dude (I mean Sir Dude...) was killed by the feared Muslim leader?? Maybe the bones are "speaking" to this guy...wooooooooo!

By Blogger medieval woman, at 6:04 PM  

Of course, the hyperbole may not be entirely unconnected to the fact that the Beeb is airing a Timewatch with him about his identification of the ruins of Jacob's Ford this Friday ;-)

Still, it'll at least make a decent change from all the post-war current affairs that the BBC has been shunting into Timewatch for the past couple of years.

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 1:51 AM  

I would like to clarify a few points regarding the article ‘First Knights Templar are discovered’ published by the Australian Daily Telegraph on 10 April 2006. The article was indeed an example of journalistic misrepresentation. I have never maintained that the human remains unearthed at Jacob’s Ford are ‘the first provable example of actual Knights Templar’. The castle of Jacob’s Ford was garrisoned by Templars when it fell in 1179, but it also contained many other soldiers, servants and builders. There is a strong possibility that one or more of the bodies discovered on site might be that of a Templar, but this could never be stated with absolute certainty. I am quoted in the article as stating that ‘never before has it been possible to trace their remains to such an exact time in history’, with the quote positioned to imply that ‘their remains’ refers to Templars, but, in fact, ‘their remains’ was a general reference to those engaged in the wider crusading endeavour of the twelfth century. Similarly, I am quoted as saying: ‘This discovery is the equivalent of the Holy Grail to archaeologists and historians. It is unparalleled’. When made, this statement did not relate to the supposed discovery of Templar remains, but to the discovery of the long lost castle of Jacob’s Ford. The story of this fortress is both fascinating and revelatory, but not for the reasons outlined in the Telegraph’s article.
Dr Thomas Asbridge
Senior Lecturer in Medieval History
Queen Mary, University of London

By Anonymous Thomas Asbridge, at 4:50 AM  

Hmmm...Dr. Asbridge I hope that you contacted the Daily Telegraph and complained - it does seem like they misrepresented your comments! What you've written does indeed sound very interesting...much more so than the Telegraph article made out. Best of luck with the work on Jacob's Ford - hopefully we'll hear more about it!

By Blogger medieval woman, at 8:43 AM  

Dr. Asbridge -- I hope you don't mind that I've moved this comment up to the main part of the blog (or will after my next lecture!). As I said in the update, a colleague did tell he thought you'd been terribly misquoted.

By Blogger Another Damned Medievalist, at 9:51 AM  

Post a Comment

Another Damned Medievalist delivers her spiel.

What is a Blogenspiel?
"...a pune or Play on Words."

Disclaimer

My opinions are my own and do not reflect the opinions of my employers at SLAC, who pretty much rock. When I talk about teaching stuff, I'm using composites of people and issues I've run across myself and know that my friends are dealing with, unless I specifically say it's a specific person. I didn't used to worry about this, but since more and more people know who I am, I just want y'all to know that I'm doing my best to blog sensitively.

Faves

Carnivalesque Button

Medieval(ish) Blogfriends

The Age of Perfection (heu mihi)
The Cranky Professor
A Corner of Tenth Century Europe
Early Modern Notes
In the Middle
Janice Liedl
Medieval Woman
Memorabilia Antonina
Modern Medieval
Muhlberger's Early History
New Kid on the Hallway
Notorious Ph.D.
Pilgrim/Heretic
Quod She
Tiruncula
Unlocked Wordhoard
Wormtalk and Slugspeak
xoom



Other Blogfriends

Advice at Your Own Risk
A Ianqui in the Village
Bitch. Ph.D.
Chapati Mystery
Confessions of a Community College Dean
Cheeky Prof
Cliopatria
Crooked Timber
Ferule and Fescue
Frogs and Ravens
Glossographia
Highly Magnified (TE)
Historianness
In Favor of Thinking
Kelly in Kansas
The Little Professor
London Marathon Prep
Making Light
My favourite news
Not of General Interest (undine)
One Bright Star
Playing School, Irreverently
Tiruncula
Professor Kinsey Lives
Reassigned Time
Rome-Coloured Glasses
Scribblingwoman
Scribblingwoman2
Scrivenings
Terminal Degree
Timna
Unsafe at Any Speed
What Now?

More Ancient/Medieval(ist) Blogs

Ancrene Wiseass
Archaeoastronomy
Baraita: the Blog
Blitztoire
Caught in the Snide
Dame Eleanor Hull
Delenda est Carthago
The English Ecliectic
Geoffrey Chaucer Hath a Blog
Got Medieval
Heo Cwaeth
Magistra et Mater
Per Omnia Saecula
Prof. H.D. Miller
Rebel Lettriste
squadratomagico
Vaulting and Vellum
,

Had I but world enough ...

Apt. 11D
All Day Permanent Red
Caveat Lector
Chilperic
Comics Should Be Good
Dictionary of Received Ideas
Emerald City
Eudaemonia's Horizon
Fafblog
Fascinating History
Go Fug Yourself
History and Culture Channel
The Intergalactic Playground
The Invisible Adjunct Channel
Jesus of the Week
John and Belle Have a Blog
John Bruce
just tenured
Learning Curves
Lenin's Tomb
Neil Gaiman
Manolo's Shoe Blog
Pandagon
Red Bird Rising
17th c.
TalkingPoints Memo
Thanks for not being a zombie
Tightly Wound
Timothy Burke
wolf angel
Yes, YelloCello


Useful Stuff

Regesta Imperii
Digital MGH
Austrian Literature Online
Whitaker's Words

Email me at Another_Damned_Medievalist AT hotmailDOTcom
(substitute the appropriate punctuation)

Subscribe to
Posts [Atom]

Archives

current
July 2002
August 2002
September 2002
October 2002
February 2003
March 2003
May 2003
June 2003
July 2003
September 2003
December 2003
January 2004
February 2004
March 2004
April 2004
May 2004
June 2004
July 2004
August 2004
September 2004
October 2004
November 2004
December 2004
January 2005
February 2005
March 2005
April 2005
May 2005
June 2005
July 2005
August 2005
September 2005
October 2005
November 2005
December 2005
January 2006
February 2006
March 2006
April 2006
May 2006
June 2006
July 2006
August 2006
September 2006
October 2006
November 2006
December 2006
January 2007
February 2007
March 2007
April 2007
May 2007
June 2007
July 2007
August 2007
September 2007
October 2007
November 2007
December 2007
January 2008
February 2008
March 2008
April 2008
May 2008
June 2008
July 2008
August 2008
September 2008
October 2008
November 2008
December 2008
January 2009
February 2009
March 2009
April 2009
May 2009
June 2009
July 2009


This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 License.
The Animal Rescue Site